Let’s be honest: we all love candles. But when that last flicker fades and all that’s left is an empty jar, the question hits—is this just going to waste? If you’ve ever wondered whether refillable candles are really worth it compared to traditional ones, you’re not alone.
We’re breaking down the key differences in the refillable vs traditional candle debate so you can choose what works best for your home, habits, and values.
What’s the difference between refillable and traditional candles?
Traditional candles are single-use. You buy the candle, burn it, and toss (or maybe recycle) the container. That’s it.
Refillable candles, on the other hand, use a reusable vessel that you keep long-term—only the wax is replaced. At ReCandle Co., our refillable candle system includes a handmade ceramic vessel and clean-burning soy wax refills that pop in and out effortlessly. It’s a better system that wastes less and feels just as satisfying to light.
Refillable candles reduce waste, and that matters
Every traditional candle you buy comes with a new jar, a new lid, new labels and new packaging. Multiply that by however many candles you burn each year, and it adds up fast. Even if you recycle the jars, not all components are accepted in local programs—and energy was still used to make and ship them.
Refillable candles simplify the whole process. You reuse the same high-quality vessel again and again, and only replace the wax. It’s a smarter, lower-waste way to enjoy candles without constantly throwing things away. And if you're trying to compare different setups, our breakdown of the best refillable candle features can help you avoid kits that are messy, unsafe, or not truly reusable.
At ReCandle Co., we also plant one tree for every order to offset shipping emissions—another small way we keep our impact low.
Clean ingredients make a big difference in air quality
Not all candles are created equal when it comes to what you’re breathing in. Many traditional candles are made with paraffin wax—a petroleum byproduct that can release questionable compounds like benzene and toluene when burned. Some also use fragrance oils with phthalates or wicks with metal cores.
Refillable candles don’t automatically mean “clean,” but they often give you more control. Ours are made with 100% soy wax, non-toxic fragrance oils, and cotton wicks—free from anything on California’s Prop 65 list. They’re safer for people, pets, and the planet.
If health is a priority in your home, refills with clean ingredients are the better choice.
The long-term cost? Refillables usually win
If you’re a casual candle user who buys one or two a year, traditional candles might not feel that expensive. But if you burn them regularly, the cost adds up—especially since you’re repurchasing the vessel every time.
With refillable candles, you pay a bit more up front for a reusable vessel, but after that you’re only buying the wax. Our candle refills are priced lower than full candles, and you can subscribe to save even more (plus get free shipping).
Over time, the refill model almost always works out to be more budget-friendly for frequent candle lovers.
Check out our candle subscription box
Aesthetics and ritual matter too
Sure, you can find plenty of stylish traditional candles. But once they burn down, most of them end up in a cabinet—or the trash. They’re not designed to last.
Refillable candles flip that. The vessel becomes a permanent part of your space, like a favorite mug or vase. Our handmade ceramic vessels are created by a local potter and glazed in timeless finishes that fit beautifully in any home. They're heat-safe, durable, and made to be used again and again.
And the act of swapping in a new refill can become a small ritual. Choose your scent. Drop it in. Light it up. It’s an intentional way to reset your space without waste.
Flexibility is built in
If you like switching up your candle scents seasonally—or even weekly—refillable candles are a game changer. With traditional candles, you’re either stuck with one scent until it’s gone, or you collect half-burned jars that clutter your shelf.
Refillable candles let you rotate easily without committing to a whole new candle every time. You can store your favorites and swap them out depending on the mood, the weather, or the time of day.
Are there times when traditional candles make more sense?
Refillables are a great solution for most people, but they might not be for everyone. If you rarely burn candles, don’t care much about waste, or love collecting limited-edition packaging, you may still prefer the traditional route.
But if you’re looking for something that’s cleaner, more sustainable, and ultimately more beautiful in your home—refillable candles are a smart switch that adds up over time.
Final thoughts
Refillable candles aren’t just a trend—they’re a better system. They reduce waste, use cleaner ingredients, cost less in the long run, and offer a more intentional experience. Traditional candles can still serve a purpose, but they’re built for one-time use. Refillables are built to last.
If you’re ready to switch from single-use to long-lasting, we’d love to help you start.
FAQ
Are refillable candles more expensive at first?
Yes—but only once. After you purchase the vessel, you’ll only need to buy the wax refills, which cost less than a full candle.
Do they burn the same as regular candles?
They should! Our soy wax refills are formulated for a clean, even burn—just like any quality candle.
Can I reuse a candle jar I already have?
You can, but it depends on the jar. It needs to be heat-safe and shaped to accommodate a refill. Our ceramic vessels are specifically designed for clean, easy reuse.
Do refills come in different scents?
Yes—we offer a rotating lineup of clean, non-toxic scents, from Amber Noir to Mediterranean Fig. You can change them up as often as you’d like.